74288 views

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.


Offline 360c

  • Drug Dealer

  • Joined: Apr 2006

  • Location:
  • Drives:
The only thing that will age a CSL is the SMG gearbox. Technology has moved on big time and I have a feeling it will feel prehistoric now, let alone in 10 years time.
BTW, the engine noise on these is insane. Just awesome!



Offline hummel


  • Joined: Nov 2007

  • Location:
  • Drives:
The only thing that will age a CSL is the SMG gearbox. Technology has moved on big time and I have a feeling it will feel prehistoric now, let alone in 10 years time.
BTW, the engine noise on these is insane. Just awesome!

Does a plain 'ol E46 M3 compete at all? Or are we talking night and day? Surely an aftermarket exhaust would sound just as good as the CSL.

And for the record... I adore the CSL !



Offline CortinaD


  • Joined: Jan 2008

  • Location:
  • Drives:
Does a plain 'ol E46 M3 compete at all? Or are we talking night and day? Surely an aftermarket exhaust would sound just as good as the CSL.

And for the record... I adore the CSL !

I haven't been in one but from outside the intake noise is night and day.



Offline 360c

  • Drug Dealer

  • Joined: Apr 2006

  • Location:
  • Drives:
Does a plain 'ol E46 M3 compete at all? Or are we talking night and day? Surely an aftermarket exhaust would sound just as good as the CSL.

And for the record... I adore the CSL !

You can't make a normal E46 sound like a CSL. The noise is on the intake side, not the exhaust side. The CSL has the massive airbox and twice the computing power in a different engine ECU. Pretty much everything on the intake side is different on a CSL.




Offline hummel


  • Joined: Nov 2007

  • Location:
  • Drives:
Ok so it's the intake noise.. defiantly hard to replicate that.

I still think the E46 M3s are good buying but the interior is starting to look a little dated...



Offline 360c

  • Drug Dealer

  • Joined: Apr 2006

  • Location:
  • Drives:
Ok so it's the intake noise.. defiantly hard to replicate that.

I still think the E46 M3s are good buying but the interior is starting to look a little dated...

BMW's have always been a bit of a trendy fashion accessory. Like any fashion, it goes out of favour once the next fashion arrives.



Offline alvchua


  • Joined: Aug 2009

  • Drives: Old junks
  • Location: Adelaide
Would definitely have been on my list of must have BMs if only that gearbox was manual!! SMG just does not cut it and my mechanic has endless tales of E36 and E46 SMG problems! Thank goodness the 1-series M coupe is 6 speed manual only!



Offline CortinaD


  • Joined: Jan 2008

  • Location:
  • Drives:
Would definitely have been on my list of must have BMs if only that gearbox was manual!! SMG just does not cut it and my mechanic has endless tales of E36 and E46 SMG problems! Thank goodness the 1-series M coupe is 6 speed manual only!

I agree with e36 smg - they all seem to be stuffed but no way on endless e46 smg problems.



Offline alvchua


  • Joined: Aug 2009

  • Drives: Old junks
  • Location: Adelaide
I agree with e36 smg - they all seem to be stuffed but no way on endless e46 smg problems.
To be fair, I've never owned a BM with SMG so have not been hit with failures etc .... all I remember was the mechanics words on SMGs....."Stay away!!" hence I have so far. ;)



Offline CortinaD


  • Joined: Jan 2008

  • Location:
  • Drives:
To be fair, I've never owned a BM with SMG so have not been hit with failures etc .... all I remember was the mechanics words on SMGs....."Stay away!!" hence I have so far. ;)

The subframe, window regulators, alternators, door trims, rtabs, power steering high pressure seem to plague the e46 more than gbox problems. Man how sad that they can't get that basic stuff right



Related Topics

  Subject / Started by Replies Last post
8 Replies
3801 Views
Last post Thu, 06 Jun, 2013 - 09:38
by Jonno
0 Replies
357 Views
Last post Wed, 16 Apr, 2014 - 05:55
by JBO


Latest Discussions

BOARD TOPIC MEMBER POSTED
[ Racing ] 2014 Bathurst 12 Hour GT fan Today at 07:39
[ Ferrari For Sale ] Ferrari 360s for sale sloppy Today at 05:45
[ Cars ] Spotted thread fivesix Yesterday at 21:06
[ Events ] Cavallino Cars and Coffee Terrey Hills NSW 1/02/2015 fivesix Yesterday at 21:04
[ Racing ] PORSCHE CLUB of SA Sprint -Time Attack # 4 Mallala 1st Feb goober Yesterday at 20:47
[ Cars ] Need a hoist PA Yesterday at 20:32
[ Cars ] The 430GT3 aka Black Beauty goober Yesterday at 20:04